Some jokers have named this phenomeon “The Crapilarity”. I am not sure whether it is written with “h”, but I guess there will be a few tasty roasted chickens on the road.
(And probably more work for good software engineers than anyone was dreaming of…)

Er… if that’s the future, how about no thanks? hehehe
Martial law in 3, 2,
I gave up on c-sec when learning how ducked it is. No one wants to deal with the Swiss cheese of a mess it is. Nor wants to be blamed for the crap that follows. The local retail store sounds better.
Huh, so turns out gutting cyber security infrastructure was a bad Idea this whole time
Naaah, it’s fiiiiiiiiine
Didn’t you hear Trump? This is just a thing that happens sometimes. Really, it’s no ones fault, and we should all just move on without learning any lessons whatsoever
Trump would never lie so I’m immediately reassured
This is not the time for finger pointing or litigation. Thoughts and prayers to the pwned.
It’s funny, looking at each of these things on Hacker News, every time it’s incompetence to blame. So that’s what the tech industry is saying to each other. This receives a lot of “well, yeah, you run A B tests and load 10mb of JS on every page, this is an obvious risk associated with that.”
Edit: yes, their bias is towards “yeah, don’t replace me with AI. Let me do my job better with AI.”
Including, that if things like Outlook being down for a day were cyber attacks, how fucking clownshoes are they? Outlook down for a day? Apple down for a few hours? Not exactly some crippling “Cyber 9/11” we’ve been told to fear for 10 years.
Risk is profitable. Any time you calculate profitable risk over odds of something taking down a system, the c-suite will choose profit.
It’s funny, looking at each of these things on Hacker News, every time it’s incompetence to blame.
Yep, people are still relying on CDNs even though they provide no real benefits, and then not even enabling the security features you’re supposed to use with CDNs.
Subresource Integrity, the ability for a site to use a CDN while blocking malicious versions of scripts, which would have blocked this whole attack, has been supported by browsers for 11 years at this point.
https://developer.mozilla.org/en-US/docs/Web/Security/Defenses/Subresource_Integrity
Silicon valley: move fast, break things.
Also silicon valley: an unexpected outage due to cyber attack means…
Ueah, we know buddy
JFC what’s being hacked now?
“In all, around 178 organizations were affected by the hack — that we know of, anyway. They include media outlets such as CNN, BBC, and Fox News; bank and finance platforms such as HSBC US and Equifax; storefronts such as IKEA and American Eagle; streaming services like Peacock; and software giants such as Zoom and Salesforce. (We did say “everything.”)”
… Well shit.
Maybe an unpopular take, but get your password managers out of the cloud and fully offline. Along with whatever else you deem critical. Things ain’t getting better before they getting far worse IMO
Maaan, I hope you’re wrong about this. Aside from device syncing, I really like knowing that all my data could be restored if my house burns down. I don’t have a second location to store a remote offsite backup of my critical data.
Or host it on your own server, but then you have to put in the work to make sure it’s secure or your in the same mess
I recently told my dad to go back to the Cellulose password manager as his main, because everything was getting too difficult for him. Looks like I won’t be far behind.
you mean pen and paper?
Yeah, a lil black notebook.
At first this sounds quite perfect offline solution, but have you mentally walked thru some disaster scenarios?
Fire/flood/tornado - Is there an off site copy?
Death - Will someone need access and able/read understand our notes to settle estate for example? My writing is horrific lol
Theft - Minimal, highly unlikely, but…
Habits - Are true strong passwords being used? Typing those in manually each time has to be a nightmare. Leading to habits of use of weak/repetitive passwords. Or storing passwords in the browser.
Not criticizing at all, whatever works for ones situation, and they are all different including ones risk level. And great to see folks putting it thru the grinder.
At the end of the day, nobody else will be there to care if your critical data is lost, only you. Cheers!
Yeah I originally got him using a password manager because of the risk of fire, flood, rats eating the book ect.
Now that I have him using the book again, we have worked out a backup method that works. I keep a copy of his book with me, and update it whenever I visit him. High latency, but it works.
What if I just move to selfhosting? I just have too many devices to be able to not have syncing for my passwords
Syncthing + KeepassXC
I set it up several years ago and have not had an issue
If you’re worried about hosting public facing services, then put all of your devices on a VPN (Tailscale/Headscale, for example) and only host on the VPN’s network.
Even from browsers?
Yes, because browsers run JavaScript and that’s where a lot of the vulnerabilities are coming from. The attack surface of a browser is gargantuan compared to the attack surface of a single-purpose password app that runs only locally.
IMO use a dedicated offline password manager such as KeePassXC, DX for android, etc. Create an emergency sheet (with any password manager) to ensure you never lock yourself out of your own vault (the biggest reason for loss of access)
Bitwarden has a good one https://bitwarden.com/resources/bitwarden-security-readiness-kit/
Offline is not as convenient, in particular for multiple devices, and everybody must make their own risk assessment vs convenience. Just my opinion, but some things are worth have fully under your own control, it has brought me good peace of mind having moved mine offline about 18 months ago.
At minimal worth spending some time looking into
What’s about hardware solution such as Yubikey? This looks pretty newt for me. However, our big company isn‘t using it. I‘m not deep in it. Curious and seriously interested.
I’ve been putting it off. It’s such a massive undertaking. But I guess it must be done.
Thanks.
Fucking assholes.
Don’t panic move, take small steps. Load the app & play with it first, test your backup routine, import one of your backups to test it works properly. Duplicate a few passwords over and try for some time, soon it will become second nature.
Keep your existing manager in place until fully comfortable. If you can, create backups of your existing manager also before you uninstall, leaving yourself some breadcrumbs back in case
You have full control, but also you are solely repsonsible for backups :)
Good luck whatever you decide
Thanks mate 👍
Have you considered self hosting a password manager like the community version of Bitwarden on your own server or VPS, this way you get the benefit of a always online server without depending on a external third party
If they’re synced yes
deleted by creator
The most depressing part is that nobody needed to hack 178 companies individually. Just poison one tool they all trusted and let the internet distribute the malware for you. We built a digital economy around shared dependencies, then acted surprised when shared dependencies became shared vulnerabilities.
Supply chain attacks are not new and very scary.
Maybe firing half the tech workers was a bad idea. Maybe creating a reinforcement loop of enshittification or layoffs was a bad idea. Maybe making lines of code changed a key performance metric was a bad idea.
Maybe firing half the tech workers was a bad idea
Then again, maybe it was a good idea, if all they’re going to do is add a zillion left_pads from npm to the project.
You get more left pads the more you cut the budget. Less time to think means more complicated software and pulling in deps you don’t need.
I can’t believe that saga happened, and still happens all the time with npm.
I want to like tools like uv/uvx but you download it for the mostly sane package manager and it installs the zero permission pull deps and execute tool for you.
In a report published Monday, security researchers at the firm Report URI said they found malicious JavaScript code in a piece of widely used software that allows businesses to customize and test their websites called Optimizely.
The nefarious scripts could swipe credit card info, redirect crypto payments, and infect iPhones and iPads with older versions of Apple’s operating systems.
In all, around 178 organizations were affected by the hack — that we know of, anyway. They include media outlets such as CNN, BBC, and Fox News; bank and finance platforms such as HSBC US and Equifax; storefronts such as IKEA and American Eagle; streaming services like Peacock; and software giants such as Zoom and Salesforce. (We did say “everything.”)
Oh, that’s really embarrassing… And yes Optimizely uses AI to function.
Add Apple to this list. Today outages for ABM, Apple School for Business, and iCloud sign in were down. Still showing issue on their site. Crazy
Makes me wonder if my ADHD keeping me from ever getting around to setting up self-hosting was a good, or a bad thing.
Best time to start was yesterday. Second best time is now. It is becoming more and more clear that that the cloud is just someone else’s computer. And now they’re all vibe-coding on their computers with your data on it.
At the very least, pull any important documents or pictures you couldn’t stand to lose and put them on a couple local drives (not a live OS, unless you’re prepared to build a server) and update them regularly. Doesn’t have to be everything, just the important stuff.
For proper redundancy, you should also keep an off-site encrypted backup with family/a friend or in a safe deposit box.
I do the latter already, but it’s not terribly convenient. I’m just not good at keeping things up to date, which is my concern with self-hosting.
That’s unfortunately the offer they give in exchange for what they get. It’s either convenience or security but not both.
I’d argue that’s only important for anything internet-facing. If your selfhosted services are locked down behind a VPN, you’re probably not going to have any issues.
And admittedly in the era of LLMs, it’s quite easy to keep stuff up to date automatically with some level of verification and sanity checking before/after the update.
For proper redundancy, you should also keep an off-site encrypted backup with family/a friend or in a safe deposit box.
IMO, you don’t need to go to the insane level of doing a safe deposit box. That would be very expensive and very inconvenient to update the files on.
There are end-to-end encrypted cloud storage solutions out there. (Personally, I use MEGA.) If they’re properly end-to-end encrypted, then they have zero knowledge of what you’re putting in their cloud storage … and also zero ability to do AI fuckery with it. It’s still somebody else’s computer and could go down at any time, but if you’re only using it as a backup for your backup, then temporary outages probably aren’t going to be a big deal. And if you don’t want to trust the service’s app to encrypt your data for you, you could always put your own layer of encryption on it first before sending it to their app to upload it – then, even if their app is compromised, your data is still safe and encrypted.
There are end-to-end encrypted cloud storage solutions out there. (Personally, I use MEGA.) If they’re properly end-to-end encrypted, then they have zero knowledge of what you’re putting in their cloud storage … and also zero ability to do AI fuckery with it. It’s still somebody else’s computer and could go down at any time, but if you’re only using it as a backup for your backup, then temporary outages probably aren’t going to be a big deal. And if you don’t want to trust the service’s app to encrypt your data for you, you could always put your own layer of encryption on it first before sending it to their app to upload it – then, even if their app is compromised, your data is still safe and encrypted.
It’s all well and good until that cloud service gets the plug pulled and everybody loses their shit unexpectedly. Kinda like what happened to MEGA’s parent, Megaupload. But I’m sure it’s totally different this time.
Could happen to any off-site backup. The extra PC at a friend’s house could get unplugged accidentally. Even the bank your safe deposit box is at could be closed down.
When it’s just a 3rd-tier backup, though, that shouldn’t be a big deal. You’d just have to find a new service and set up a new off-site backup if that happened. It would only be a major problem if you’re fantastically unlucky and MEGA just happens to get shut down at the same time you (for presumably unrelated reasons) just lost your primary copy and main backup copy at the same time.
(And if your data is so important that you can’t tolerate even that minuscule amount of risk, you can go further by using multiple independent cloud-hosting companies redundantly. One might go down, but it’s pretty much unthinkable that both would permanently go down with complete loss of customer data and you happen to lose your main copy and all local backups at the same time.)
I have ADHD and self host, it’s doable! Just make sure you write everything down. Host a wiki platform or Obsidian or something to keep it moderately organised.
I self host but only local. I don’t really need it on the go. I don’t trust myself to expose it to the net.
Yeah. I’ve been self-hosting since before AI and botnets, and my security profile has evolved quite a bit in þat time. It’s also made self-hosting way less fun; I hate spending time defending against fucktard script kiddies.
use NoScript and LocalCDN religiously + no online-connected password managers ever
Futurism sucks,but I’m glad some post finally said it correctly.
















