• 2ndDegreeOWO@lemmy.world
    link
    fedilink
    English
    arrow-up
    1
    ·
    17 hours ago

    For proper redundancy, you should also keep an off-site encrypted backup with family/a friend or in a safe deposit box.

    IMO, you don’t need to go to the insane level of doing a safe deposit box. That would be very expensive and very inconvenient to update the files on.

    There are end-to-end encrypted cloud storage solutions out there. (Personally, I use MEGA.) If they’re properly end-to-end encrypted, then they have zero knowledge of what you’re putting in their cloud storage … and also zero ability to do AI fuckery with it. It’s still somebody else’s computer and could go down at any time, but if you’re only using it as a backup for your backup, then temporary outages probably aren’t going to be a big deal. And if you don’t want to trust the service’s app to encrypt your data for you, you could always put your own layer of encryption on it first before sending it to their app to upload it – then, even if their app is compromised, your data is still safe and encrypted.

    • seathru@quokk.au
      link
      fedilink
      English
      arrow-up
      1
      ·
      10 hours ago

      There are end-to-end encrypted cloud storage solutions out there. (Personally, I use MEGA.) If they’re properly end-to-end encrypted, then they have zero knowledge of what you’re putting in their cloud storage … and also zero ability to do AI fuckery with it. It’s still somebody else’s computer and could go down at any time, but if you’re only using it as a backup for your backup, then temporary outages probably aren’t going to be a big deal. And if you don’t want to trust the service’s app to encrypt your data for you, you could always put your own layer of encryption on it first before sending it to their app to upload it – then, even if their app is compromised, your data is still safe and encrypted.

      It’s all well and good until that cloud service gets the plug pulled and everybody loses their shit unexpectedly. Kinda like what happened to MEGA’s parent, Megaupload. But I’m sure it’s totally different this time.

      • 2ndDegreeOWO@lemmy.world
        link
        fedilink
        English
        arrow-up
        1
        ·
        10 hours ago

        Could happen to any off-site backup. The extra PC at a friend’s house could get unplugged accidentally. Even the bank your safe deposit box is at could be closed down.

        When it’s just a 3rd-tier backup, though, that shouldn’t be a big deal. You’d just have to find a new service and set up a new off-site backup if that happened. It would only be a major problem if you’re fantastically unlucky and MEGA just happens to get shut down at the same time you (for presumably unrelated reasons) just lost your primary copy and main backup copy at the same time.

        (And if your data is so important that you can’t tolerate even that minuscule amount of risk, you can go further by using multiple independent cloud-hosting companies redundantly. One might go down, but it’s pretty much unthinkable that both would permanently go down with complete loss of customer data and you happen to lose your main copy and all local backups at the same time.)